http://www.ComputerBob.com/guides/guide_cpu_cooling.php
pixel

Mini.

ComputerBob's Guide To CPU Cooling

by ComputerBob

January 25, 2003

Last Updated February 2, 2003

Introduction

As most people know, too much heat can damage a PC's CPU (main brain). A CPU that constantly runs too hot will have a shorter life than one that runs cooler, and could also cause problems like random shutdowns and the loss of important data. Many modern CPUs have a safety feature that will slow them down or shut them off before they can be damaged by heat, but, I've read that if someone forgets to install its heatsink and fan before powering it up, an AMD Athlon XP CPU can overheat "burn up" in only a few seconds. This article details how I was able to significantly reduce my PC's motherboard and CPU temperatures.

Cool The Case

When looking for ways to cool a PC's CPU, the first thing to do is reduce the overall temperature inside the PC's case, because that's where the CPU "lives." Typical airflowThe best way to do that is to create an airflow that brings in cool air from the lower front of the case and exhausts hot air out the back of the case. After all, the fan that cools your PC's CPU can't work very well if it's blowing hot air onto your CPU. Don't make the mistake of thinking that your power supply's fan will cool your entire PC, like it did in older PCs. A power supply fan is designed to keep the power supply cool, not circulate fresh air throughout an entire PC. Add to that the fact that modern high-speed CPUs, hard drives, graphics cards, sound cards, and other components generate much more heat than slower, older components. The result is that modern PCs often need 2 or more fans in addition to their power supply fan, to draw cool, fresh room air into the PC and to exhaust hot air out of it. When I built my PC, its case came with an 80mm exhaust fan mounted in the back. Knowing that a bigger fan can move more air than a smaller fan running at the same speed, I moved that 80mm fan to the front of my PC's case to serve as an intake fan, and I went shopping for a 92mm exhaust fan at a local computer store. I compared the noise and CFM (cubic feet per minute) ratings on all of the fan packages. There were quiet fans that didn't move much air, and there were noisy fans that moved a lot of air. In the end, I found a combination of noise level and CFM that I could live with by buying a 92mm Antec "SmartFan." I mounted the 92mm fan in the back of the case, where the 80mm fan had originally been, to exhaust the hot air created by my PC's high-speed components. Of the two types of fans, the exhaust fan is more important than the intake fan, but if you have an intake fan in the front of your PC and an exhaust fan in the back of your PC, they work together to increase the flow of fresh air through your PC's case, which helps all of the components run cooler.

Another thing that can affect airflow through the case is the type of cables that you use, and their placement in the case. For example, many cases and motherboards come with one or more flat, gray, ribbon data cables that are used to connect floppy drives, hard drives, and CDRW drives. If you use those, try to position them in such a way that they don't block the airflow through your computer. For example, you can try to lay their flat sides up against the outsides of the case. Instead of flat ribbon cables, I bought round data cables that contain all of the same wires as the flat cables, but in a round shape that lets air flow around them more easily. My 450 watt power supply has many power wires, but I moved the ones that I'm not using into the front/upper area of the case, in the unused 5.25" drive bays above my CDRW drive. Now my unused power cables are completely out of my PC's internal airflow.

Cool The CPU

Once you have established a system for good airflow through the PC's case, it's time to maximize the cooling of your CPU. I've read that an AMD Athlon XP processor can be damaged if it ever runs hotter than 70 degrees Celsius (158 degrees Fahrenheit), but most people try to keep their CPU running much cooler, in the 30-50 degree range (86-122 degrees Fahrenheit). When it comes to CPU coolershopping for an effective and efficient CPU cooler, there are many cooler manufacturers, and each one offers several different models, with online prices ranging from under $5 to about $150 or more (U.S.D). Some coolers are made of solid aluminum, some are made of solid copper, and others combine a copper core with aluminum fins. Some are even liquid cooled. Some have fast, noisy fans, while others have larger, slower, quieter fans. A few (like mine) have a manual control that lets you change the speed of the CPU cooling fan to get the right amount of cooling with the least amount of noise. Each model of CPU cooler is designed for a specific type of CPU (i.e. AMD Athlon XP) running in a specific range of speeds (i.e. up to 1700+). Be sure to buy a CPU cooler that is specifically designed for your specific CPU, or for an even faster version of your CPU than you have. If you're planning to overclock your CPU (force it to run at a faster speed than normal), then it's even more important that you buy a cooler that is capable of dissipating the extra heat that your overclocked CPU will generate. My CPU is a 2100+ but my CPU cooler is designed to cool any AMD Athlon XP CPU up to the 2800+ model. I think it is a very good value, because it cost me only $15 with free shipping, but it does a great job of cooling (see below). I found ExtremeTech and Tom's Hardware and Anandtech and Overclockers to be good sources of information on CPU coolers. Those sites are also good sources of information on all PC components and on building a PC -- plus, all 4 sites have very helpful and educational online support forums. The CPU manufacturers themselves (i.e. Intel, AMD, etc.) often publish a list of CPU coolers that they recommend for their specific CPUs -- you can't go wrong if you buy a manufacturer-recommended CPU cooler, unless you're going to overclock your CPU, in which case the recommended cooler may not be suitable for you. I bought my cooler -- and all the other components to build my PC) from NewEgg.com, a highly rated online store that lets you search for coolers by CPU type, manufacturer, price, etc., and has photos, descriptions, and buyers' comments about nearly every product it sells. NOTE: If your CPU's warrantee states that you must use its OEM-included CPU cooler, then you should keep the OEM cooler, in case you ever need to file a warrantee claim on your CPU.

Leadtek Setup

I had ordered a Leadtek motherboard to use in my new PC. I had read many complaints about the stock heatsink/fan that comes with AMD Athlon XP CPUs -- mostly that its fan had quit after a few months, and that it didn't do a very good job of cooling the CPU. So, I bought and installed a highly rated CoolerMaster CPU cooler instead of the stock CPU cooler that had come with my CPU. The CoolerMaster's fan and heatsink are each much bigger than the stock CPU cooler's, to help keep the CPU as cool as possible. And the CoolerMaster that I bought has a manual speed control that lets you adjust the speed of the CPU fan to achieve your own desired balance between noise and cooling ability. Between the surface of the CPU and the bottom surface of the heatsink, I used a thin layer of the generic white heat transfer grease, to help transfer the heat from the CPU into the heatsink. Details: Leadtek K7NCR18D-Pro motherboard, generic white silicon heat transfer grease, CPU and RAM running in BIOS-set Turbo mode (overclocked).

Asus Setup

When the USB ports turned out to be defective on my Leadtek motherboard, I returned it for a refund and bought an Asus motherboard. I reassembled my PC with the Asus motherboard, using the same CoolerMaster CPU cooler that I had used with the Leadtek motherboard. Because I had read that its high silver content allows it to transfer heat very efficiently, I bought a tube of Arctic Silver heat transfer grease to use instead of generic heat transfer grease, and I polished the CPU-mating surface of the CoolMaster heatsink's copper core with 400 sandpaper. Details: Asus A7N8X motherboard, Arctic Silver heat transfer grease, CPU and RAM running in BIOS-set Aggressive mode (overclocked).

Testing Conditions

I monitored my CPU and motherboard temperatures for both my Leadtek and Asus setups for two days apiece, using each motherboard's BIOS temperature-monitoring feature, with the CPU at idle (not doing any work). Throughout the monitoring, the following conditions were constant:

  1. Case: Chieftec TWR DH-01B with 450 watt AMD-approved power supply
  2. Intake and exhaust case fans were both running at normal speed
  3. CPU: AMD Athlon XP 2100+
  4. CPU Cooler: CoolerMaster HAC-V81
  5. Manually adjustable CoolerMaster CPU fan running at 4115 RPM
  6. Video Card: Albatron AGP 4x TNT2 Model 64 with 32MB RAM
  7. Sound Card: Used Sound Blaster PCI 128
  8. The sound card and AGP graphics card were installed in the same slots in each setup
  9. RAM: Crucial 2 x 256MB PC-2100 DDR running in dual-channel sync mode
  10. Hard Drive: Western Digital WD400JB 40GB 7200 RPM Special Edition with 8MB cache
  11. CDRW Drive: TDK 48/16/48
  12. Floppy Drive: Teac 3.5"
  13. Keyboard: Microsoft Natural Elite
  14. Mouse: Logitech M-BJ69 optical corded
  15. Round data cables connecting the hard drive and CDRW drive on separate IDE channels

Results

Criteria Leadtek Asus Asus
Ambient room temperature 19C / 66F 19C / 66F 24C / 75F
Lowest motherboard temperature 32C / 89F 23C / 73F Not tested
Highest motherboard temperature 34C / 93F 27C / 80F Not tested
Motherboard temperature after running overnight 33C / 91F 23C / 73F 28C / 82F
Lowest CPU temperature 40C / 104F 30C / 86F Not tested
Highest CPU temperature 41C / 106F 34C / 93F Not tested
CPU temperature after running overnight 40C / 104F 30C / 86F 35C / 95F

Comparing Results At The Same Ambient Room Temperature

Comparing Results At Different Ambient Room Temperatures

Conclusions

The Asus setup ran significantly cooler than the Leadtek setup, even in a significantly warmer room. Because more than one variable changed between the two setups, I can't attribute the significant temperature differences between them to just one variable. I suspect that each of the following were contributing factors, in various degrees (pun intended):

  1. The Asus motherboard's "Aggressive" overclocking mode runs cooler than the Leadtek motherboard's "Turbo" overclocking mode.
  2. Polishing the mating surface of the CoolerMaster's copper heatsink improved its ability to transfer heat.
  3. The Arctic Silver heat transfer grease worked better than the generic heat transfer grease.
  4. The superior layout of the Asus motherboard allowed cables to be routed for increased airflow through the case.

So, if you're thinking of building your own PC, you'll have fewer problems if you do your homework and make sure that it's going to run nice and cool.